Transsexual v Transgender

Do the words we use to describe ourselves stop us being truly ourselves?

For me, the word “transsexual” was permission. I wanted to transition male to female. This was a recognised phenomenon: something that people did, often successfully, so I could too. And it was also definition. It involved hormones and surgery, and after going full time I found myself wanting surgery. I waited a year before seeking surgery, and had it ten months after that, privately. More than ten years later, I started to regret it.

The concept allowed me to transition, which made me much happier, which was the thing I wanted more than anything else in the world. Now, I believe that I wanted surgery not because I was innately that sort of human who is really of the other sex so needs surgery, but because of how I understood who was allowed to transition, and what transition meant. I could not get the gender expression without the physical alteration.

So the word was permission, but also constraint. How can I explain this? I wanted surgery, and listening to the psychiatrist dictate a letter recommending it is one of my strongest memories of complete happiness. And now I regret it, and believe that I wanted it as a symbol, the price to pay for transition, not for it itself. Not for how it would make lovemaking different. It altered how I saw myself, but I saw myself as “post-op TS”, having completed the process, rather than “pre-op TS”, having a way to go.

It is possible that there are people who need to transition to be fully ourselves, and a smaller number of those who need surgery to be themselves; and it is also possible that people want surgery to convince themselves and others that they are truly transsexual.

Chest masculinisation is different. It affects how you are seen. I thought the questions were, “Am I transsexual? Will I be happier if I transition?” Now I think breaking it down is useful.

  • Who am I, really?
  • What will enable me to be most fully myself in society?
  • Do I want to change my name?
  • Do I want to change my presentation?
  • Do I want to change my body, and if so, how?

It would not be a box marked “transsexual”, and possibly another box marked “transgender”, but a whole mass of individuals. Changing the body by facial hair removal, taking hormones, surgery, would be assessed according to what they gained for the individual, rather than whether the individual fitted the one box. One change would not mean that another was inappropriate.

The words are permission to do what we want to do, and also a moral goad, to encourage others to treat us in particular ways. I am not some sort of pervert man wanting to ogle women, I am a trans woman, who should be accepted in women’s space. That makes some people enforce the boxes. A “transsexual”, who has had surgery, is tolerable in women’s loos, but a “transgender” M-F who does not want surgery would not be. I hope most people don’t think about it that deeply. I am “a trans woman”, so I can be expected in women’s loos.

I want the acceptance as a woman to go with presentation as a woman, without physical changes. It would be humiliating to endure groin inspections, even if that meant I was admitted. But transition does not necessarily mean acceptance by others, or even by yourself. We can call any objection to our presence in women’s spaces “transphobic” if we like, and a lot of women are on our side, but some still object.

The words we use can make some ways of thinking possible, and others more difficult. Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan, wrote, Seeing then that truth consisteth in the right ordering of names in our affirmations, a man that seeketh precise truth, had need to remember what every name he uses stands for; and to place it accordingly; or else he will find himselfe entangled in words, as a bird in lime twiggs; the more he struggles, the more belimed. Now, we create new words when we need them, but they should not constrain our acts. And I came across this quote in relation to faithfulness in sexual relationships, but it applies to much more than that: We should be aware that these behaviours are incredibly complex, and are likely to be influenced by many factors, including social and cultural effects, personality, genetics and life experiences.

8 thoughts on “Transsexual v Transgender

    • I have never read Hobbes. Someone quoted For words are wise mens counters, they do but reckon by them: but they are the money of fools, which I found continues, that value them by the authority of an Aristotle, a Cicero, or a Thomas, or any other Doctor whatsoever, if but a man. It’s the kind of quote that might go round the Internet, and there’s this useful site providing context. From that I found another quote which kind of fits. Hobbes argues that words can make you wise, or foolish, above or below the uneducated masses. It is the same idea as “A little learning is a dangerous thing”.

      Sometimes, online- mostly on Quaker facebook groups, and on particular blogs- people try to find truth together by precise, careful use of words. Unfortunately a lot of people, and sometimes I myself, just want to win, or to bamboozle.

      Leviathan is in Job 41:

      19
      From its mouth go flaming torches;
      sparks of fire leap out.
      20
      Out of its nostrils comes smoke,
      as from a boiling pot and burning rushes.
      21
      Its breath kindles coals,
      and a flame comes out of its mouth.
      22
      In its neck abides strength,
      and terror dances before it.
      23
      The folds of its flesh cling together;
      it is firmly cast and immovable.
      24
      Its heart is as hard as stone,
      as hard as the lower millstone.
      25
      When it raises itself up the gods are afraid;
      at the crashing they are beside themselves.
      26
      Though the sword reaches it, it does not avail,
      nor does the spear, the dart, or the javelin.
      27
      It counts iron as straw,
      and bronze as rotten wood.

      Liked by 1 person

    • You don’t know what it will be like before it happens. I believe we want it because of how we imagine a trans woman ought to be, rather than from some innate need. That does not mean the need and the belief are not real, or people would wake up and refuse it.

      When I went in to hospital, they said, “Let us know of any second thoughts, and we will be delighted to talk you out of it.” I knew it was my choice, even as the mask went over my face.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. “l believe we want it, (that life changing and highly empowering srs), because of how we imagine a trans woman ought to be, rather than from some innate need.”
    lndeed. How perceptive of you to so succinctly summarize the key distinction between a true proper, (and really quite rare), transsexual, and the poorly, loosely defined and highly ubitquitous transgender.

    Like

    • You’re not a sock puppet of “Sock Puppet”, are you?

      0.1% is hardly “ubitquitous”. What enables you to imagine such a distinction is probably other personality traits, rather than some imagined “true” transsexuality.

      One trans woman transitioned, reverted, and transitioned again. When she transitioned she wrote a book “At last I am my true self”. When she transitioned again, she said she had reverted because of the loss of male privilege- she could not stand being ignored and patronised. But when she reverted initially, she made a complaint against her psychiatrist, saying she had some other sort of mental condition and should not have been allowed to transition.

      We are who we are. That is difficult. It may make you feel better to imagine you are “true TS”, but do not tear others down.

      Like

    • You misunderstand. I don’t think there is a distinction, or different groups. Rather there is an idea of what a “transsexual” is, involving surgery. Surgery need not be necessary. We tell ourselves stories, in order to live; but those stories change over our lives, and do not necessarily match some innate nature. Some have surgery, and are happy, or unhappy.

      Like

All comments welcome.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.