Feminine men

Renoir- femme assise au bord de la merRenoir, jeune femme assiseAfter writing my own post, I googled “Feminine men”, and found this post on Thought Catalog. The comments from women are encouraging in that they all agree, but discouraging in that they say things like People often think I’m really weird when I tell them all this and I know no one who is like me too.

Then I found Love Red Nails, first “Women marrying feminine men“. The writer talks of wanting her partner in a dress for the wedding. They often share clothes. Out came my internalised femme-phobia: it is alright for a man to be feminine, but cross-dressing is going too far, I thought. I resented her mentioning this, thinking it made a lovely idea tawdry and fetishistic, even though I express myself female all the time. Trans women are encouraged to distance ourselves from transvestites- it sometimes seems we are more acceptable if we have a “medical condition”.

It is about sex. Of course it is. How could finding a partner not be? But it is also about relating to the world as a whole, in all of life. That I should still think of dressing feminine as a dirty little fantasy shows how pervasive femme-phobia is. I read what the male commenters have to say on both these posts, and feel they shouldn’t be saying these things, they should keep quiet about it, even as I begin to say the same myself. All my fear comes out. I clicked Submissive men and read Sensitive or submissive men are very different from normal (sic) guys in their behavior. What’s normal? People are like this! What is the feeling about camp v “straight acting” gay men atm?

Then Lucy writes about women who like feminine men, whether  they are cross-dressers or are “on the passive side and not afraid to be vulnerable”. Um. Passive. Vulnerable. Not well regarded, and not comfortable even for me. That physically delicate and vulnerable type of man gives me a sort of protective instinct. I just want to hold him tight and keep him safe from the big bad world. I never decided to be that way, it’s just what comes up in response to what I see around me. That is what I want in a woman, though it makes me ashamed. I still feel I should be stronger than that.

I don’t read much contemporary fiction, but am unaware of a novel in which a couple where the woman “wears the trousers” (not an attractive phrase; better than “pussy-whipped”) have a happy lasting relationship. Or on the telly- Stuart on LA Law, perhaps.

The Wall St Journal, no less, says “Women don’t want macho men” when their countries have good health-care systems, because the masculine man is more likely to get divorced, and less good with children. In passing, the female writer suggests the feminine men are more likely to get cuckolded- which is part of the femdom fantasy.

Also, there was Youtube, a series of pictures of men in “women’s” clothes, some of them growing or mimicking breasts, some not.

I want to say, How fantastic! Liberation! But I am still ashamed and frightened, and want to keep quiet about it. Is that “feminine”?

10 thoughts on “Feminine men

  1. Shame and fear and worry….feminine? Not really, except perhaps that women still tend to be disadvantaged, and disadvantaged citizens probably feel these emotions more often….but fairly universal, in fact. People will always generalise about others – see? – and that really matters not a lot. You are as you are….

    xxxxx 🙂


  2. Sooooo I am a horrible friend. Even if it is JUST an internet friend. It has been waaaay too long since I was on your blog. So I had better come up with some pretty darn good to lead off with.

    “…I am still ashamed and frightened, and want to keep quiet about it. Is that “feminine”?”
    Well, shame is destructive and fear leads to death. So whether it is feminine or not is immaterial. It is not good for you. I know. Easy for me to say some 10,000 miles across the pond from you but recognizing shame and fear as being bad is a good first step. You should not be ashamed of who you are and you certainly should never be afraid.

    God bless you Clare. 🙂


    • It is always lovely to hear from you, however long the gaps. And I am still thinking of your protagonist’s moral issues.

      Shame feminine like a spoon’s convexity produces its concavity. Feminine to think- others are different, therefore I must be wrong, rather than others are different, therefore they must be wrong. Maturity, seeing more than one way of being human, comes later.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. i do think people should dress and they please, and do not follow trends or social constructs. so, if a man feels more confident and happy wearing women’s clothes, i’d say “go for it! do what makes you happy!”.

    once i was walking down the street and a stunning woman was going in my direction. when she was close to me, i saw that it was actually a man (probably a trans). and my only thought was: wow, she’s hotter than me!

    so, yes i do think man can be sexy in women’s outfits if they like to wear it, because it’s natural. natural is always sexy. 😀

    Liked by 1 person

All comments welcome.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.